Select Page
Berean Baptist Church > Blog > A Restrained Heart is Not a Renewed Heart

While preparing to preach John 3, I was struck by the kind of man to whom Jesus said, “You must be born again.” Nicodemus was not openly immoral. He was a Pharisee, a ruler of the Jews, and “the teacher of Israel.” His life displayed religious discipline, biblical knowledge, and outward respectability, yet Jesus did not tell him that he needed more instruction or greater self-control. He told him that he needed to be born again, from above, in order to have a new birth produced by the Holy Spirit.

That is where the phrase came from: A restrained heart is not necessarily a renewed heart.

Sin may be restrained for many reasons. Family expectations, fear of consequences, discipline, concern for one’s reputation, civil law, or one’s religious background may keep them from acting upon every sinful desire. Such restraint is beneficial as it protects families, churches, and communities from harm. However, outward restraint cannot change the inward disposition of the heart. A person may avoid drunkenness, adultery, dishonesty, or angry outbursts while remaining proud, self-righteous, unbelieving, and alienated from God. Improved conduct is not the same as spiritual life.

This is why Paul writes in Titus 3:5 that God “saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit”. Every part of that verse matters. Salvation is not God’s reward for our righteous works. It originates in His mercy. We do not regenerate, cleanse, recreate, or renew ourselves. God saves through “the washing of regeneration,” which is the cleansing associated with new birth, and through the renewing work of the Holy Spirit.

Regeneration and a renewed heart are inseparably related. Regeneration is God’s once-for-all act of imparting spiritual life to a sinner. A renewed heart is the inward result of that life-giving act. Regeneration names what the Spirit does, while the renewed heart describes what the Spirit produces. God changes the person from within so they see their sin, stop relying on themselves, believe in Christ, and begin to love what God loves. When the Spirit gives new life, the sinner sees Christ as his only hope and believes in him.

Paul calls this “the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit.” These are not two unrelated stages of salvation. Together they describe God’s cleansing and life-giving work. The language recalls God’s promise in Ezekiel 36, “I will sprinkle clean water on you, and you shall be clean…. And I will give you a new heart…. And I will put my Spirit within you.” It also explains Jesus’ words in John 3:5, “Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God.” God does more than restrain sinful actions; He cleanses sinners and gives them new hearts through His Spirit.

Titus 3:6-7 show us this work is Trinitarian. The Father pours out the Spirit “richly through Jesus Christ our Savior,” so that, “being justified by his grace,” we become heirs of eternal life. The Father saves according to His mercy, the Son accomplishes our salvation, and the Spirit applies it by giving new life.

A renewed heart does not produce perfection immediately, and it also does not remove the need for restraint. Since believers still battle sin, we need to resist sin and utilize the Spirit’s power to overcome sin. We no longer merely fear sin’s consequences, rather, we increasingly hate sin because it dishonors God.

The question, then, is not, “Have I learned to control myself?” It is, “Has the Holy Spirit cleansed me, and brought me to faith in Jesus Christ?” A restrained heart may produce a respectable life, but only a regenerated heart results in eternal life.

Berean Baptist Church